Since we had our discussion a week or so ago about the circumstances within the Republican party that made Trump’s ascent possible, and whether or not the comparison to Hitler is justified, quite a bit has happened. Most notably, we’ve seen Trump’s aggressive, authoritarian rhetoric intensify. And, with this ramped up rhetoric, we’ve seen a marked increase in acts of violence perpetrated against protestors, especially protesters of color, at his rallies.
In the past week or so, we’ve seen peaceful protesters at Trump events violently shoved and sucker-punched to the head. We’ve also heard Trump’s supporters yelling things like, “Go to fucking Auschwitz,” and “Go back to Africa.” And, in spite of these things, Trump continues to encourage his followers to “knock the crap out of” those in the audience who are there to protest, going so far as to offer to pay the legal fees of those who step up and actually do it. “We’ve become weak,” he says to his supporters, recalling a better time in American history when such people would have been “carried out on stretchers.” One of the things contributing to our decline as a nation, he says, is that “There are no consequences to protesting anymore.”
“Knock the hell out of them. I promise you I will pay for the legal fees. I promise.” -Donald Trump
What I find the most troubling is the fact that Trump is increasingly using words and phrases intended to dehumanize those whom he sees as impediments to his quest to “Make America Great Again.” “These are not good people,” he recently told a crowd of his supporters, indicating a group of protestors. “They contribute nothing,” he added. He then went on to say, “These are the people that are destroying our country.” [At the risk of losing credibility by once again drawing the comparison to Hitler, the way Trump talks about protesters reminds me a great deal of how the Nazis talked about the Jews, referring to them as der untermensch, or “the subhuman.”]
Given these comments made by Trump, and the enthusiasm by which they’ve been met, is it really any surprise that, swept up in the moment, people might begin to act in ways that they wouldn’t in everyday polite society?
Alvin Bamberger, the 75 year old Korean War veteran caught on tape a last week violently shoving a young black woman from a Trump rally in Louisville, Kentucky, explained the circumstances in a letter of apology written to the president of the Korean War Veterans Association. “Trump kept saying ‘get them out, get them out’ and people in the crowd began pushing and shoving the protestors,” Bamberger wrote. “Unfortunately a lot of this behavior was happening right next to where I was standing, and, having been pushed to the floor myself, my emotions got the best of me, and I was caught up in the frenzy. I physically pushed a young woman down the aisle toward the exit, an action I sincerely regret.” He also claimed repeatedly not to be a racist, and asked to be “forgiven for (his) actions.” While we can debate Bamberger’s sincerity, I don’t think there’s any doubt that the environment in that room, fostered by Trump, was a huge contributing factor.
Trump’s ascendency has brought things to the mainstream that have always been buried just below the surface. Trump has made it OK for people to say things out loud that, up until a few months ago, they may have just muttered to themselves in their own cars. Trump, through his words and actions, has shown racists that they can come out of the closet without fear of retribution. And, as we’re seeing, they’re taking full advantage of the opportunity.
A lot of us thought that it could never happen here. While we knew that there was the potential for such things to happen, we thought that our political leaders would stop it, or that the media would pull the plug before it got this bad. It hadn’t occurred to us that a good many of our political leaders might actually nurture it along, as it promised to serve their agendas, or that the media might encourage it, seeing as how it’s good for ratings… And now we find ourselves collectively staring into the abyss, asking ourselves why we let it get this far… How did we get to a point where the Republican candidate for President of the United Sates is actually saying that, if we want to “be great again,” we need to increase the level of violence in society?
President Obama, speaking about Trump at SXSW yesterday, asked the audience, “How can you be shocked?” He went on to say, “This is the guy, remember, who was sure that I was born in Kenya — who just wouldn’t let it go. And all this same Republican establishment, they weren’t saying nothing. As long as it was directed at me, they were fine with it. They thought it was a hoot, wanted to get his endorsement.”
Here’s a clip from Obama’s speech.
…”What is happening in this primary is just a distillation of what’s been happening inside their party for more than a decade. I mean, the reason that many of their voters are responding is because this is what’s been fed through the messages they’ve been sending for a long time — that you just make flat assertions that don’t comport with the facts. That you just deny the evidence of science. That compromise is a betrayal. That the other side isn’t simply wrong, or we just disagree, we want to take a different approach, but the other side is destroying the country, or treasonous. I mean, that’s — look it up. That’s what they’ve been saying.
So they can’t be surprised when somebody suddenly looks and says, you know what, I can do that even better. I can make stuff up better than that. I can be more outrageous than that. I can insult people even better than that. I can be even more uncivil. I mean, conservative outlets have been feeding their base constantly the notion that everything is a disaster, that everybody else is to blame, that Obamacare is destroying the country. And it doesn’t matter whether it’s true or not. It’s not, we disagree with this program, we think we can do it better — it’s, oh, this is a crisis!
So if you don’t care about the facts, or the evidence, or civility, in general in making your arguments, you will end up with candidates who will say just about anything and do just about anything. And when your answer to every proposal that I make, or Democrats make is no, it means that you’ve got to become more and more unreasonable because that’s the only way you can say no to some pretty reasonable stuff. And then you shouldn’t be surprised when your party ultimately has no ideas to offer at all…
Now, I think it’s pretty clear, it’s just a matter of time before there is bloodshed. It’s inevitable at this point. I knew it the moment I read what John McGraw, the Trump supporter who sucker-punched the man at the rally in North Carolina, had said to reporters after the incident. “The next time we see him, we might have to kill him,” McGraw said of the victim. “We don’t know if he’s ISIS. We don’t know who he is, but we know he’s not acting like an American.”
And Trump isn’t doing anything to decrease the tension. He’s not asking his supporters to be civil. He isn’t ratcheting down his rhetoric. In fact, as I noted earlier, he’s pushing the boundaries even further… Here, if you haven’t yet seen it, is video of his recent statements compiled by Rachel Maddow.
Trump, for what it’s worth, did come out this morning and say, “I don’t condone violence,” but, at the same time, he continued to maintain that none of it we’ve seen thus far has been his fault, as, in each case, the episodes were instigated by protestors who were sent by his democratic opponents, especially Bernie Sanders, who he refers to as “our communist friend.” As the folks at Talking Points Memo point out, however, while Trump has “repeatedly claimed that instances of crowd violence at his rallies occurred when protestors – ‘bad dudes’ – attacked his supporters and his supporters fought back. Until the events last night in Chicago, there is no evidence that anything like this ever happened. Not once.” Tensions, however, are increasing on both sides. As it becomes more and more likely that Trump will be Republican nominee for President, people are beginning to push back. As we saw yesterday in Chicago, where Trump protestors took to the streets, things are beginning to intensify. And, at this point, I don’t know how we can turn things around. So, as I see it, it’s not a matter of if someone will die, by when.
The only question I have is how people will react when the first person dies at a Trump rally. Will that be the end of Trump, or will it just be the beginning?