Over the past several years, we’ve seen a number of instances in which fake news stories, having been seeded through bots by entities that want to stoke the fires of racial animus and political tribalism in the United States, have spread like wildfire across the internet thanks to real people, who, it would seem, care more about the “emotional truth” of what they share on social media than its actual legitimacy. It happens across the entire political spectrum. Some of us on the left, who believe Trump to be a giant, television-obsessed baby-man, actually believed it when fake news broke about how he wanted to have access to a 24-hour “gorilla network”. And, on the right, we had people actually believing that Hillary Clinton had murdered a young man by the name of Seth Rich in order to keep him quiet about a Democratic plot to illegally influence the outcome of the 2016 election and frame the Russians. We live in truly crazy times, and it’s only going to get worse, as our adversaries around the globe now know just how easy it is, through the careful placement of false news items across social media, to get us at one another’s throats, to the point where we’re shutting down the federal government, talking about disbanding NATO, etc… Why build missiles and put them off our coast, when, through the placement of several stories about how Barack Obama is a closet Muslim who refuses to recite the Pledge of Allegiance and Hillary Clinton is a cult leader who feeds on the blood of infants, you can create just as much chaos, and do the same amount of damage to the underpinnings of our democracy?
Thankfully, it never really caught fire, but those of us who live in Ypsilanti were almost caught up in one of these ridiculous and divisive non-stories just a few days ago, when someone got it in their head to misrepresent an awesome community-building program at the Washtenaw International High School and Washtenaw International Middle Academy — a program intended to increase empathy, and decrease instances of intolerance and racism on the shared Ypsilanti campus of the two schools. [As you my recall, it was almost exactly one year ago when a racially charged email was sent anonymously to students of the middle school, and administrators have done a number of things to ensure that it never happens again, and that all students feel both safe and respected.]
Well, here’s how it went down…
I got a text message Friday afternoon alerting me to the fact that Ypsilanti Community Schools had put out a statement saying that it had been brought to the attention of school administrators that “a YCS school or classroom” had potentially been participating in something called “Edgy Day,” a reoccurring event during which “white students (have to say that they are) sorry for their privilege.” The note went on to say that YCS does not condone this practice, and, having been made aware of it, would investigate, stop it from happening, etc.
Having two children in YCS schools who have never been forced to apologize for half-whiteness, and knowing a thing or two about how conservative conspiracy theories spread across the internet, I responded to this post, encouraging the folks at YCS to take it down, and not just assume that, because they received an email stating that a YCS student had been forced to apologize for their white privilege, they should believe it. And, with that, myself and others began looking into the propagation of “Edgy Day” stories on social media.
Well, guess what? There were only four instances of the phrase having been used on Facebook, and all four had put out the evening before. And, most notably, all four were identical, and put out by accounts which appear to be bots… Here they are… As you’ll notice, some, by the time I took these screen shots, had already been shared multiple times.
And all four of these, it would seem, were put out shortly after the following Twitter post from a pro-Trump account known for sharing conspiracy theories, especially as they related to Muslims, and other non-white Americans, attempting to take over the country.
The above post contains the following screen capture, which appears to come from Facebook. And, that, it would seem, appears to be how all of this started. I’ve been looking for a while, but I’ve yet to find the “Refuse Common Core” account which is said to have authored it. As you’ll note, nowhere in it does it say that this happened at YCS. The only person to make that connection was the person above, who shared the post on Twitter, linking back to several rightwing commentators and politicians, in hopes, no doubt, that it would be picked up nationally.
As with most good conspiracy theories, there is a little truth in it. Washtenaw International High School and Washtenaw International Middle Academy, as I alluded to above, did have an event on Friday called Equity, Diversity, Justice, and Inclusion (EJDI) Day. But white students were neither “made to feel like crap,” nor instructed to bring an item of value from home to “give to a minority.” Here, with more on what actually happened, is a letter to parents from Nhu Do, the principal of both schools.
Dear WIHI and WIMA students and families,
We are writing to thank all students and staff for participating in our Equity, Diversity, Justice, and Inclusion (EDJI) Day activities today. The purpose of this event is to promote empathy, equity, and inclusion for all students. Student leaders in partnership with teachers planned and participated in an activity and discussion examining our different social identities and discussed how we can develop empathy and understandings for others.
We were made aware of an inaccurate account of what happened in school today: At no time were students required to apologize for their privilege. This is misinformation that unfortunately negates the dedicated and meaningful work our staff and students do to make our world a safer, more inclusive place for all. We are committed to promoting peace and empathy through education.
Overwhelmingly, students and staff shared their positive feedback on the value of engaging in discussion about inclusion for all and we are grateful for your support, engagement, and open-mind. Please contact me if you have any questions about our commitment to promoting cultural proficiency and equity.
Sincerely,
Ms. Do
So, now we have people on the internet sharing misinformation on “Edgy Day,” and chalking it up as yet one more instance of white people being cruelly pushed from their rightful place in society. Given what we’ve seen on the internet over the course of the past few years, I’m inclined to think the whole thing was a fraud from the beginning, but I suppose it’s possible that a YCS parent really did misunderstand what his or her children told them about “EDJI Day,” and then went right to Facebook to vent in their anti-common core group. As I don’t think there are a lot of “anti-common core” crusaders sending their kids to International Baccalaureate schools like WIMA and WIHI, however, I think it’s safe to at least consider the possibility that someone, having read about the schools’ Equity, Diversity, Justice, and Inclusion Day events, decided to create a fictional post about how white children in Ypsilanti were being made to given their possessions to classmates of color, in hopes of drawing the outrage of Donald Trump’s aggrieved white supporters, who honestly believe that anti-white racism is the most significant problem we face as a nation. Fortunately, in this instance, it seems as though the story withered. Someone made the decision to push the story, and others amplified it, but, thankfully, it never broke though to a wider audience because people were vigilant and they shut it down fast. Good work, Ypsilanti.