A little over a year ago, I posted a rant here about the “new” Elbow Room. Actually, it wasn’t really about the “new” Elbow Room so much as it was about those folks who felt it necessary, when talking about how great the “new” Elbow Room was, to go the extra step and heap shit on the memory of the “old” Elbow Room, a place where I saw many a damned good show. Here’s a clip from that post:
The “Ann Arbor News” has a feature today on Ypsi’s infamous Elbow Room, which is now under new management. The article essentially says that it’s now safe for University of Michigan students to come out and have a beer there. As someone who’s done his fair share of drinking at the old Elbow Room, I found it a bit offensive…
I wish the new owners all the luck in the world and I hope the Elbow Room stays a vibrant venue for live music (there aren’t many places for live, non-corporate music these days), but I wish they would stop framing the story in terms of how bad the old place was. If anything, I think they should be drawing on the colorful history of the place, not poking fun of it.
When I wrote that, I had no idea that I’d be coming back to the subject over a year later. But, just now I read on my friend Leighton’s site that the shit’s still bubbling. The most recent flair-up comes courtesy of Stewart Beal, the Ypsi developer working to rehab Depot Town’s Thompson block. Beal, who recently announced that an even “newer” iteration of the Elbow Room would be a tenant in his development, had the following to say about the fellow who oversaw the transition from “old” Elbow Room to “new”.
“What attracted me to him is he took over management of the Elbow Room, which was a rundown business with a lot of clientele you wouldn’t want to hang out with, and turned it into a hip and happening place,” Beal said of Garris. “He’s really brought the music scene to life, and I’m excited about this venue in Depot Town.”
By way of background, I should mention that the Elbow Room is being forced to leave their home on Washington Street due to structural issues with their building… Hence the move to Depot Town.
I like the “new” Elbow Room, and I wish them all the luck in the world when they make the move to Depot Town (assuming they can wait the year that it will take for the Thompson block to be rehabbed). We desperately need a good venue for loud music in this town. I have my doubts that Depot Town, with its antique shops and quiet sensibilities, would be the best place to see that happen, but I wish them luck. If they still take chances on weird local acts, and pull bands like Sleepytime Gorilla Museum and Captured by Robots, I’ll be there. With all due respect to them, however, the “new” Elbow Room is no more “hip and happening” than the “old” Elbow Room was. [And can we please put a moratorium on the use of “hip” when talking about things in Ypsi?]
I don’t have anything to else to say. I just think it’s stupid and shortsighted to tear down what came before instead of building on it. And, again, I don’t blame Garris or anyone else at the “new” Elbow Room. I realize this was said by a real estate developer who was trying to put a positive spin on his own long-stalled project, but still… It’s bad form. And, if it continues, it’ll kill the “newest” Elbow Room before it’s doors even open.