11/19/08

Permalink 09:59:26 pm, by mark - Other

how much blame do the unions deserve?

At the risk of pissing off the majority of my readers, I feel as though I have to say that the unions of this country have, over the past several decades, in my opinion, done a piss poor job. They’ve allowed the American people to forget that unions, through their hard fought battles, were responsible for limiting the workweek to 40 hours, and ensuring a living wage for laborers. They haven’t articulated their value. They’ve allowed the prevalent union narrative in this country to become one of greedy and gluttony. If you asked 100 people on the street for their impressions of unions, you might have one or two mention the workplace safety regulations they were responsible for, or the fact that, thanks to their efforts, we no longer have kids working in coalmines. The rest would likely talk of drunks being paid $70 an hour to occasionally show up and push a broom. Unions have allowed this to happen. Focusing on the dollars, they’ve lost sight of the big picture. Union leaders should be the heroes of the American people, but instead, today, we see them taking the blame for what’s become of the United States automotive industry. It didn’t have to be this way, and it pisses me off…

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: mark [Member] Email
Sorry for the rant. I love the unions, at least in theory. It just bugs the hell out of me that they've somehow lost control of the message. They got greedy. And they lost sight of what really matters.
PermalinkPermalink 11/19/08 @ 22:42
Comment from: Brackache [Visitor] Email
The SAG strike led to the reality show pandemic.

You can't argue with results.

Seriously though, everything is like in nature. Big corporations, unions, governments, whatever. Some prey population is too big and is eating all the foliage, so some preditors come along and eat them so they get thinned and the foliage comes back, then the preditors get too numerous and some starve so the prey come back, on it goes. Shit dying is just how things correct themselves and move on. No system is death proof.

I've been watching Northern Exposure.
PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 00:10
Comment from: fakenamesonananonblogaresilly [Visitor] Email

How many hrs is that worker WORKING to get that $70/hr average. I don't like incomplete data. My observation is that the big wages for line workers comes with lots guaranteed hrs (the mandatory part of Guaranteed Overtime). And that reliance on guaranteed OT caused people to count on income that frankly their actual skillset would not earn them otherwise.

Guaranteed overtime helps the company. They have 1 worker working the hours of 2, for the price of benefits for 1.

Unions have definitely had mission creep and lost track of the real issue they were formed to address once they won the big battles that led to their formation.

Demonizing workers, though, is always the company angle. It has taken about 55 years, but they have managed to turn most in the country against something that benefits the people and the company at the same time, at the price of removing some of the corporate ability to act capriciously.

And this campaign is wrapping up during a time when they are taking every penny away and out of the country-- and then wondering why no one here can afford their product.

PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 06:26
Comment from: West Cross is the Best Cross [Visitor] Email
I think the issue is the perception of the $70/hr drunk worker, not rather or not there really is such a person. Like Mark is saying, that is what a lot of people think of when they think of unions, and it hamstrings any good they may be trying to do. It's their own fault, though. Now that working standards are higher for everyone (thanks in part to the unions) it is much easier for the employer to play the "everything is great, why do you need a union" card. The unions haven't given a good answer to that question and their relevance has suffered because of it.
PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 09:21
Comment from: CKL [Visitor] Email
I'm just glad to see someone say something good about unions. Like Mark, I'm a fan. I know, from history, what life was like without them. Even with the corruption, we're much better off.
PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 09:40
Comment from: Robert [Visitor] Email
It's just a natural tendency of mass populations to drift away from the understanding of what got them all that they have. I don't blame the unions for not being able to keep the awareness fresh in people's minds. It's a losing battle no matter how well you fight it. I think it's still pretty clear we're all in for some very hard lessons as to our collective amnesia and failure to continually maintain our view of a bigger picture.
PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 10:44
Comment from: The Exterminator [Visitor] Email
Kind of how people forget why they don't get malaria, yellow fever, typhus, or plague.
PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 15:07
Comment from: Stalagtite [Visitor] Email
The unions are for the most part corrupt and they protect individuals who shouldn't be protected.

People died so that we could have unions, and I'm afraid that people are going to have to die again to get them back.
PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 16:30
Comment from: Robert [Visitor] Email
It's too bad there isn't an immunity one could have to exploitation.
PermalinkPermalink 11/20/08 @ 20:32
Comment from: Robert [Visitor] Email
From the looks of things, you people are gonna need all the scapegoats you can get.
PermalinkPermalink 11/22/08 @ 15:21
Comment from: Old Goat' Wife [Visitor] Email
You say "The unions are for the most part corrupt and they protect individuals who shouldn't be protected." But Unions protect all members, no exceptions, that is their beauty. Management however is lazy and doesn't like manage. Sure the union will defend a worker, but it is managements job to document when workers don't do their job. Instead you see lazy managers ignore and enable lazy workers. You see this in schools, factories, and the few remaining workplaces with union protection. In my workplace all raises are based on merit, and again dependent on management's opinion of the quality of my work. I would take union protection over merit any day.
PermalinkPermalink 11/23/08 @ 06:55

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, a>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))

syndicate this site
email me


Fetching comments



In and around Ypsi
Arbor Update
Downtown Ypsi
The Corner Brewery
Leighton
East Cross
EMU Talk
Mouse Musings
Doulicia
Rev George
Suds and Soliloquies
Eric 2.0
The Lynne Show
Common Monkey Flower
90% Crud
Trusty Getto
Sam's Thoughts
Corpus Callosum
Past the College Grounds
Ed Vielmetti
Loose Tea
Growing Hope
Ubu
Homeless Dave
Steve Pierce
Beezy's
Sustainable Ypsi
Two Fell Swoops
Prospect Park
Tales from the Bean
Matt Callow
Urban Homesteader
Hooray Forever
Ypsi City Desk
Ypsi Citizen
Ann Arbor Chronicle
Bike Ypsi

Support MM.com


Blogs
Hamtramck Star
Hauling Secrets
The West Virginia Surf Report
John August
Caliblog
Collin Burton
Dave Pollard
SS Trudeau
Clusterfuck Nation
Podunk's Valet
Srah Blah Blah
Ryan is Hungry
Have Money Will VLog
Naval Gazing
Freshtopia
Great Lakes Law
Supergay Detroit


Political Blogs
Daily Kos
Think Progress
One Good Move
firedoglake
Talking Points Memo
Juan Cole
Progressive Blog Alliance
Suburban Guerilla
Eschaton
Roger Ailes
David Corn
Rude Pundit
John Conyers
Crooks and Liars
Consortium News
Common Dreams
Michigan Liberal
Michigan Messenger



Information Communities
Metafilter
Boing Boing
popurls
TailRank
Monkeyfilter
History News Network
Internet Archive
Wikipedia
Disinfopedia
Corante
The Huffington Post



Credible Sources
New York Times
Washington Post
New Yorker
The Gaurdian
Frontline
Google News
Christian Science Monitor
Village Voice
Atlantic Monthly
Harpers
FreshAir
Bill Moyers
Paul Krugman

Watchdogs
ACLU
People for the American Way
Southern Law Poverty Center
Sunlight Foundation

Arts and Culture
Red Hot Jazz
American Visionary Art Museum
We Make Money Not Art
Current TV
Pre-War Blues
Mercury Theatre
Dismuke's Virtual Talking Machine
WFMU
Arwulf
Learning to Love You More
Ullage Group
Yes Men

Misc

Login...
Register...

Archives

b2evolution