12/19/05

the god who wasn't there, and the bullshit that was

In the spirit of this bloody war we’ve been waging against Christmas and its persecuted practitioners, I felt it was my duty to link to the trailer for Brian Flemming’s new documentary, “The God Who Wasn’t There.” In the film, Flemming, perhaps best known as the author of the off-Broadway hit “Bat Boy: The Musical,” suggests that Jesus Christ, much like Santa Claus, is a figment of our collective imaginations.

Personally, I would have settled for a film outlining the apparent discrepancies between the teachings of Jesus and the actions of his followers here on earth, or even perhaps a film calling into question his virgin birth, but Flemming decides to go one giant step further, suggesting that the man described in the Christian gospels never even existed. When asked by the LA Times why he chose to question Jesus’ mere existence rather than just his divinity, Flemming said, “I think that the idea that an individual could be the son of a god is already so ridiculous it doesn’t need to be debunked.” Judging from that response, I’m guessing he’s not too interested in finding common ground. One just hopes for his sake that the fervent believers in this country are a bit more willing to turn the other cheek than they were in Amsterdam, when another ballsy filmmaker decided to call the legitimacy of a very popular religion into question.

…OK, as long as I’ve gone this far, I might as well go all the way and also link to the episode of Penn and Teller’s “Bullshit” in which they debunk the Bible.

Happy Holidays.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Tony Buttons Esq. [Member] Email
In two thousand years I bet they'll be saying that Bat Boy never existed.
PermalinkPermalink 12/20/05 @ 10:01
Comment from: dorothy [Member] Email
immaculate conception has nothing to do with jesus. it is the accepted church doctrine that mary was the only human born without original sin. the idea that jesus was begotten of the holy ghost is called the virgin birth, not the immaculate conception.
PermalinkPermalink 12/20/05 @ 10:53
Comment from: Collin [Member] Email · http://fizzleandpop.blogspot.com/
I really doubt that I want to "go there", but here I go anyhow. How was Mary born without original sin? Is she from off planet?

Thanks for the links Mark.
PermalinkPermalink 12/20/05 @ 11:51
Comment from: It's Skinner Again [Member] Email
I believe the dogma is that Mary's original sin was deleted from the first moment of her conception, since God (who is off planet) already had plans for her. But I admit I don't understand the mechanics of all this.

The evidence that Jesus existed is kind of shaky. But there certainly were early Christians, so something must have happened.
PermalinkPermalink 12/20/05 @ 12:52
Comment from: mark [Member] Email
Thank you for the note, Dorothy. I'll edit my post accordingly.

As for this film, I probably should have said it in the post, but, while I intend to watch it with an open mind, I'm doubtful that it'll convince me that there was no Jesus. While I have a great many issues with Christianity, especially as it's being practiced now in the US, whether or not Jesus really existed isn't a question in my mind.
PermalinkPermalink 12/20/05 @ 21:33

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, a>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))

syndicate this site
email me


Fetching comments



In and around Ypsi
Arbor Update
Downtown Ypsi
The Corner Brewery
Leighton
East Cross
EMU Talk
Mouse Musings
Doulicia
Rev George
Suds and Soliloquies
Eric 2.0
The Lynne Show
Common Monkey Flower
90% Crud
Trusty Getto
Sam's Thoughts
Corpus Callosum
Past the College Grounds
Ed Vielmetti
Loose Tea
Growing Hope
Ubu
Homeless Dave
Steve Pierce
Beezy's
Sustainable Ypsi
Two Fell Swoops
Prospect Park
Tales from the Bean
Matt Callow
Urban Homesteader
Hooray Forever
Ypsi City Desk
Ypsi Citizen
Ann Arbor Chronicle
Bike Ypsi

Support MM.com


Blogs
Hamtramck Star
Hauling Secrets
The West Virginia Surf Report
John August
Caliblog
Collin Burton
Dave Pollard
SS Trudeau
Clusterfuck Nation
Podunk's Valet
Srah Blah Blah
Ryan is Hungry
Have Money Will VLog
Naval Gazing
Freshtopia
Great Lakes Law
Supergay Detroit


Political Blogs
Daily Kos
Think Progress
One Good Move
firedoglake
Talking Points Memo
Juan Cole
Progressive Blog Alliance
Suburban Guerilla
Eschaton
Roger Ailes
David Corn
Rude Pundit
John Conyers
Crooks and Liars
Consortium News
Common Dreams
Michigan Liberal
Michigan Messenger



Information Communities
Metafilter
Boing Boing
popurls
TailRank
Monkeyfilter
History News Network
Internet Archive
Wikipedia
Disinfopedia
Corante
The Huffington Post



Credible Sources
New York Times
Washington Post
New Yorker
The Gaurdian
Frontline
Google News
Christian Science Monitor
Village Voice
Atlantic Monthly
Harpers
FreshAir
Bill Moyers
Paul Krugman

Watchdogs
ACLU
People for the American Way
Southern Law Poverty Center
Sunlight Foundation

Arts and Culture
Red Hot Jazz
American Visionary Art Museum
We Make Money Not Art
Current TV
Pre-War Blues
Mercury Theatre
Dismuke's Virtual Talking Machine
WFMU
Arwulf
Learning to Love You More
Ullage Group
Yes Men

Misc

Login...
Register...

Archives

b2evolution