08/25/05

Permalink 09:42:50 pm, by mark - Politics, Alternative Energy

conservation is unamerican

As long as I’ve already set the precedent of stealing large blocks of text from Think Progress tonight, and since I still have half a glass of wine, here’s a little something more… This has to do with a clause buried deep within the new Bush federal fuel efficiency bill that makes it illegal for states to enact legislation more aggressive than the federal government. Here’s how the folks at Think Progress explain it:

With the Bush administration asleep at the wheel, states have been forced to take the lead in combating global warming. Last year California adopted rules which “will require a 30 percent cut in carbon dioxide emissions from cars and light trucks by 2016, a target that will most likely be met by big increases in fuel efficiency.”

The approach is gaining popularity. The New York Times reported last Sunday:

”The Bush administration hates the California plan, and industry has challenged it in court. But George Pataki of New York and other Eastern governors have pledged to emulate it — which means the states may end up carrying a ball that Congress dropped. That would not be a bad thing at all.”

Yesterday, the Bush administration released new federal fuel efficiency standards. (Not surprisingly, the standards will do little to increase fuel efficiency and may actually encourage automakers to produce bigger, more inefficient vehicles.)

Buried on page 150 of the draft rule is a provision that would totally undermine state efforts to curb CO2 emissions:

”[A] state may not impose a legal requirement relating to fuel economy, whether by statute, regulation or otherwise, that conflicts with this rule. A state law that seeks to reduce motor vehicle carbon dioxide emissions is both expressly and impliedly preempted.”

In other words, no state can have a fuel efficiency rule any different than the federal government. So much for state’s rights.

So, once again the Republicans have proven themselves to be the party of state’s rights… until something doesn’t go their way.

Just so we’re clear on this, individual states are coming forward and taking action to conserve resources and cut our dependence on foreign oil, thus increasing our security, and instead of being praised for their sacrifice, they’re being told that what they’re doing is illegal.

If you feel as strongly about this as I do, you can send a letter to the presidents of the automotive companies, who are the ones pushing Bush for this legislation, and let them know how you feel. An on-line form has been set up by the folks at Environmental Defense.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Steven [Visitor] · http://hamtramckstar.com/
I thought I could count on the Republicans for State's Rights issues. I say we secede and legalize gambling, prostitution, and marijuana.
PermalinkPermalink 08/25/05 @ 23:04
Comment from: Tony Buttons [Visitor]
You missed this sub-clause:

"All drivers of biodiesel vehicles will be shot in the head seven times."
PermalinkPermalink 08/26/05 @ 10:58
Comment from: Mike Davis [Visitor]
This is sickening. As far as I can tell it is another completely indefensible position yet the political opposition to this is limp. The problem behind this is that voters are too entrenched.

Americans treat their politics like college football; they loyally support their "team" at all costs until death. Right or wrong gets thrown out the window and there is no switching of sides on different issues. The heart of this problem is the two-party state. I firmly believe that a one or three party state is better than a two party state, because at least then you deal with individual issues instead of lumping them together in some kind of two product choice.

Republicans who want more stringent fuel efficiency standards aren't willing to "cross the aisle" to get them, because then they'd give up other things they value which might be more important to them. Instead of being able to act now we sit here in a political quagmire and wait for the time when the tides will turn and Democrats are elected. It's sad.

My advice is if you want to have a better democracy, support a third party candidate, even if you disagree with them. It's better for your country tomorrow.
PermalinkPermalink 08/26/05 @ 12:40
Comment from: chris [Visitor]
OK, that is the MOST unRepublican thing I have ever read. It is balls to the wall federalism at its best. It is more flip flop than W's platform for his first campaign where he stated he would be anti-international interventions.

And Mark, seriously, are you Tony?
PermalinkPermalink 08/26/05 @ 21:24
Comment from: Marie Antoinette [Visitor] · http://www.cockybastard.blogspot.com
You'd think that it wouldn't take much to encourage Americans to drive smaller cars--SUVs are "out", hybrid technology is getting cheaper every day, and gas is at an all-time high. I didn't think it was possible to mess this up, but Bush has managed to do it.
PermalinkPermalink 08/27/05 @ 00:11

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, a>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))

syndicate this site
email me


Fetching comments



In and around Ypsi
Arbor Update
Downtown Ypsi
The Corner Brewery
Leighton
East Cross
EMU Talk
Mouse Musings
Doulicia
Rev George
Suds and Soliloquies
Eric 2.0
The Lynne Show
Common Monkey Flower
90% Crud
Trusty Getto
Sam's Thoughts
Corpus Callosum
Past the College Grounds
Ann Arbor is Overrated
Loose Tea
Growing Hope
Bluish Barn
Ubu
Homeless Dave
Steve Pierce
YpsiDixit
Sustainable Ypsi
Two Fell Swoops
Prospect Park
Tales from the Bean
Matt Callow
Urban Homesteader
Hooray Forever
Bike Ypsi

Think Global: Act Dingell

Support MM.com


Blogs
Hamtramck Star
Hauling Secrets
The West Virginia Surf Report
John August
Caliblog
Collin Burton
Dave Pollard
SS Trudeau
Clusterfuck Nation
Podunk's Valet
Srah Blah Blah
Ryan is Hungry
Have Money Will VLog
Naval Gazing
Freshtopia


Political Blogs
Daily Kos
Think Progress
One Good Move
firedoglake
Talking Points Memo
Juan Cole
Progressive Blog Alliance
Suburban Guerilla
Eschaton
Roger Ailes
David Corn
Rude Pundit
John Conyers
Crooks and Liars
Consortium News
Common Dreams
Michigan Liberal



Information Communities
Metafilter
Boing Boing
popurls
TailRank
Monkeyfilter
History News Network
Internet Archive
Wikipedia
Disinfopedia
Corante
The Huffington Post



Credible Sources
New York Times
Washington Post
New Yorker
The Gaurdian
Frontline
Google News
Christian Science Monitor
Village Voice
Atlantic Monthly
Harpers
FreshAir
Bill Moyers
Paul Krugman

Watchdogs
ACLU
People for the American Way
Southern Law Poverty Center
Sunlight Foundation

Arts and Culture
Red Hot Jazz
American Visionary Art Museum
We Make Money Not Art
Current TV
Pre-War Blues
Mercury Theatre
Dismuke's Virtual Talking Machine
WFMU
Arwulf
Learning to Love You More
Ullage Group
Yes Men

Misc

Login...
Register...

Archives

b2evolution