[The following post is kind of rambling. I apologize in advance for the stream-of-consciousness nature of it.]
A few nights ago, half joking, I posted on Facebook that I was considering the possibility of bestowing a “Local Person of the Year” award in Ypsi, the same way that Time magazine does every year for the nation as a whole. Well, the conversation evolved in a direction that I hadn’t really foreseen… People actually took the idea seriously… By the time the online conversation finally died down, not only had several dozen people been nominated, but people were actually committing themselves to the idea in significant ways. Rob Hess, the owner of Go Ice Cream, offered to contribute a sizable amount of ice cream to a gift basket for the winner, suggesting that others do the same. “You should just pick a person,” Rob said, “Then we can load them up with gifts like a goddamn walking, talking Ypsilanti Christmas tree.” And, then, someone by the name of Ginny Golembiewski contacted me, offering to organize a parade on behalf of the recipient, which would culminate at the person’s home, where members of the community would bestow baked goods, and share a toast in their honor.
To be honest, the last thing I need right now is one more big project, but, judging by all of the responses, this thing clearly has potential, and I feel as though I should probably see it though, wherever it might lead… The question is how.
As I see it, I have two options. I could either do it myself, and just pick someone, giving them a plaque saying something, like “Mark Maynard’s Favorite Ypsilantian of 2014,” or I could do it right, drafting a committee representative of the city, agreeing to a number of guiding principles, taking nominations, and then going through the process of meticulously weighing the merits of every nominee… The problem, of course, is that the people I’d want to serve on the committee would likely be people who themselves should be considered for the honor.
And that’s another thing to consider. Would it really be an honor? Would someone want an Ypsilantian of the Year award to begin with, let alone from a blog that an old guy writes in his bed, while chewing on cough drops? Of course, I don’t guess I’d even have to mention the blog. I could just start up a whole new entity to present the award, calling it something grandiose like The Society for the Betterment of Ypsilanti, right?
And then there’s the question of just where to draw the geographic boundaries. As this site has just as many readers in Ann Arbor as it does in Ypsilanti, should we include them as well? Or is it better to just focus closer to home and honor someone who’s busting his or her ass to make life here better? (People in Ann Arbor get enough awards, don’t they?)
Or, I could just make the whole thing a joke, and give the award to myself, and then continue to do so on an annual basis for the rest of my life, watching my living room wall slowly fill with “Ypsilantian of the Year” plaques. Or, would that be too douchey? If so, I could change the name of the award, calling it something like, “I’m Being The Best Mark Maynard That I Can Be Award.” And, every year, on the last day of December, I could walk out of my front porch, bestow it upon myself, and give a little speech. I think that would be nice. Or, better yet, I could give it to a different Mark Maynard each year. I like the idea of a “Best Mark Maynard of the Year” trophy that could travel from town to town between those of us named Mark Maynard.
So many things to think about.
[Time passes.]
…OK, here’s what I’m thinking. There’s too much of risk in trying to do it correctly. Invariably, people will be disappointed. They’ll argue that the panel of judges isn’t representative enough. They’ll argue that our criteria for judging was skewed in favor of one person, or one type of person. They’ll argue that we picked the wrong person. They’ll argue that we didn’t even consider people who we should have… This, of course, had occurred to me early on, but I thought that it would still be worth it. I thought that the ensuing conversation, even if it might get a little ugly, would be a good thing, as it would get people in the community talking about what we collectively value, and what we’re all doing to make life here better. Now, though, I’m thinking that the risk outweighs any possible benefit that we might enjoy as a community. So, for that reason, I’m deciding against the “do it right” option, at least for the time being.
What I’m thinking instead is that I’ll just do it myself, and I won’t call it the “Ypsilantian of the Year” award. I’ll call it something like, Mark Maynard’s “From My Admittedly Limited Knowledge of the Community in which I Live, this is the Ypsilantian Who I Think Kicked the Most Ass This Year, and I Apologize if You Disagree, and I’ll Try to Pick Someone Better Next Year” Award.
So, if you have people to nominate, please do so by leaving a comment here. Just name the person, and briefly explain why it is that you think they’re awesome, and how they made life here in Ypsi better.
As for the prize which will accompany the award, if you’d like to join Go Ice Cream and contribute toward it, just send me an email. I’ll probably go and buy an old bowling trophy or something, and have a new brass plate etched for it. At ten cents a letter, or whatever it is, Mark Maynard’s “From My Admittedly Limited Knowledge of the Community in which I Live, this is the Ypsilantian Who I Think Kicked the Most Ass This Year, and I Apologize if You Disagree, and I’ll Try to Pick Someone Better Next Year” Award will cost a small fortune, but I reckon it’s worth it.
And, if all goes well, I’ll hand it over to someone on New Year’s Eve.